Millennials in the garden

According to this article in The Telegraph, Monty Don, an English horticulturist and TV host say's we shouldn't waste our time trying to convince Millennials into the garden. According to Don, "I think we put far too much interest in trying to get ten to 20 year olds interested in gardening. I think you should do everything you can to try and get them interested up to the age of 10.” 

I agree. No one pushed me into horticulture, or the garden. My interest developed on it's own without any encouragement from the trade. As Don say's, "When you’re 15 whatever your parents tell you you should do, you’re not going to do it. Any self respecting 15-year-old [will rebel] and so they should."

"I think much better to make sure they have access to it up to the age of 10 and of course don’t take it away at that point, and just let them come.”

The marketing attempts from most of the trade organizations geared towards millennials fall on deaf ears. Millennials will migrate to the garden on their own, if they choose. Likely it will be the realization that in the garden the hope for our future rests. Not with new technology, new media, or slick ad campaigns, but in the garden where one can make a difference that is real and dynamic. Horticulture is the future, and millennials will realize that when they do. 

Our future customers are in debt, and out of work

The greatest challenge garden centers face is the declining size of the next generation, as well as the enormous debt the next generation is responsible for. The New York Times had this article concerning the student debt the next generation is amassing. Imagine coming out of college owing 150,000 USD and trying to find work in one of the worst job markets in decades. These are the people who are going to buy houses and shop at the local garden center?

Not only is the next generation in debt, and facing an awful job market, but there are just fewer of this generation to replace the boomer generation who is retiring. If the garden center trade is waiting for economic recovery to take place and get back to the way things we’re, it’s going to be waiting a long time. There are just too many garden centers, home stores, box stores, and wholesale suppliers selling plants for the market. Further shrinkage of the trade is inevitable.

I know most in our trade are tired of hearing about how the next generation doesn't want to garden like their parents did. I imagine it’s because we just don’t know what to do. I was talking to a friend who is a wine maker, and that industry is looking at the same thing. They are not buying or drinking wine like their parents did. There is way too much acreage in this State of California growing grapes for the need. How many of these young people can afford $20 USD on wine? How many just don’t drink wine? That trade is shrinking just like the garden center trade.

The younger generation is interested in growing food to eat, and some of the same gardening their parents did. There just isn't enough of them with homes and steady jobs to support the trade. I expect to see the results of this trend first in Europe where the youth unemployment is skyrocketing. It’s already begun and those of us who wish to stay in this trade will have to figure out how to service a shrinking demographic who's interests are different than the generations who helped build the trade.

The only certainty is a smaller and poorer demographic will be our next generation of customers. What can be done to survive and prosper in this environment? I think the future is very bright for those who can figure out which path to take. There will just be a lot fewer of us on that path.

If people don't buy stuff, how are we going to stay in business?

I found this Fast Company article titled, "Why Millennials Don't Want to Buy Stuff" interesting (it's not just Millennials doing this either). From the first paragraph we read, "Millennials seem to have some very different habits that have taken both established companies and small businesses by surprise. One of these is that Generation Y doesn't seem to enjoy purchasing things."

As the owner of a small garden shop business this kind of news can be quite disturbing, or liberating. We also read that, "The biggest insight we can glean from the death of ownership is about connection. This is the thing which is now scarce, because when we can easily acquire anything, the question becomes, 'What do we do with this?' The value now lies in the doing."

Last week I had a discussion with some folks on Facebook after I posted this,"Seems customers with the most gardening experience use the least amount of fertilizer, They've figured out the 'nature' of their garden". Someone said, "nice, but not good for business is it?" I believe my answer may be a way forward for those who see this new "non-ownership" mentality showing up around them.

Here is my answer, "what's happened is those successful gardeners we're in many cases taught their methods here. We showed them a way to grow better without the use of synthetic fertilizers. Now that they are successful the're more into gardening than ever, and as such are expanding their gardens or trying new varieties. So by saving them the time and money on unsustainable gardening (and unhappy gardeners), we have enthusiastic customers who come in time and time again."

How will your business or venture survive and thrive in this new "non-ownership" world. It's not just the Millennial generation that is doing this. I see it with many people who are tired of the responsibility and costs associated with the owning of objects. It's a trend I don't see abating any time soon. It's actually a huge plus for small garden businesses who see the positives of this. It's about the process of helping someone become a better gardener (the experience), not selling a bag of fertilizer (stuff) when they really don't need it.